Showing posts with label end of life. Show all posts
Showing posts with label end of life. Show all posts

Thursday, April 21, 2016

Improving End of Life Care


BMJ, April 18, 2016
Murray SA, Murray IR

To allow people the deaths they want, end of life care must be radically transformed.


Monday, February 1, 2016

When I Die

An end-of-life doctor faces his own end-of-life from a glioblastoma.

When I Die.

Peter Rasmussen was always able to identify with his patients, particularly in their final moments. But he saw himself especially in a small, businesslike woman with leukemia who came to him in the spring of 2007, not long before he retired. Alice was in her late fifties and lived in a sparsely furnished farmhouse outside Salem, Oregon, where Rasmussen practiced medical oncology. Like him, she was stubborn and practical and independent. She was not the sort of patient who denied what was happening to her or who scrambled after any possibility of a cure, no matter what the cost. As Rasmussen saw it, “She had long ago thought about what was important and valuable to her, and she applied that to the fact that she now had acute leukemia.”

This is an excellent article in the January 2016 Harper's Magazine.  It was sent to us by Kathy McKnight.
Dr. Rasmussen and family members

Wednesday, December 23, 2015

End of Life Discussions

Though most patients wish to discuss end-of-life (EOL) issues, doctors are reluctant to conduct end-of-life conversations. Little is known about the barriers doctors face in conducting effective EOL conversations with diverse patients. This mixed methods study was undertaken to empirically identify barriers faced by doctors (if any) in conducting effective EOL conversations with diverse patients and to determine if the doctors’ age, gender, ethnicity and medical sub-specialty influenced the barriers reported.






Sunday, December 13, 2015

Five Wishes


Five Wishes is a United States advance directive created by the non-profit organization Aging with Dignity. It has been described as the "living will with a heart and soul."
The Five Wishes (Online Version)
        1: The Person I Want to Make Care Decisions for Me When I Can't
        2: The Kind of Medical Treatment I Want or Don't Want
        3: How Comfortable I Want to Be
        4: How I Want People to Treat Me
        5: What I Want My Loved Ones to Know

History (About Five Wishes)
Five Wishes was originally introduced in 1996 as a Florida-only document, combining a living will and health care power of attorney in addition to addressing matters of comfort care and spirituality. With help from the American Bar Association's Commission on Law and Aging and leading medical experts, a national version of Five Wishes was introduced in 1998. It was originally distributed with support from a grant by the Robert Wood Johnson Foundation. With assistance from the United Health Foundation, Five Wishes is now available in 27 languages and in Braille.  More than 18 million documents have been distributed by a network of over 35,000 partner organizations worldwide. An online version called Five Wishes Online was introduced in 2011 allowing users to complete the document using an online interface or print out a blank version to complete by hand.

Saturday, December 12, 2015

The Stanford Letter Project


"Our goal is to empower all adults to take the initiative to talk to their doctor about what matters most to them at life's end. Our research has shown that while almost all doctors agree that it is important for them to have end-of-life conversations with their patients, most doctors struggle with these conversations. Our research has also shown that patients from all ethnic backgrounds agree that it is important for them to have end of life conversations with their doctors. However, patients do not quite know how to initiate these conversations. 

The Letter Project will help you write a letter to your doctor using a simple template. The template is based on extensive research and is specifically designed to help you voice the key information your doctor needs in order to provide end-of-life care to you that is congruent with your values and wishes. 

Use our letter template, write your letter, print it and discuss it with your family and your doctor. The letter template is available in several languages. Many people have already written their letter. Write your letter now!"


Imagine Quality at End of Life


Katy Butler's memorable book Knocking on Heaven's Door is almost a textbook for care of the failing elderly patient.  From the dust jacket: "Like so many of us, the Buler always assumed her aging parents would experience healthy, active retirements before dying peacefully at home. Then her father suffered a stroke that left him incapable of most activities of daily living. Her mother was thrust into full-time caregiving, and Katy Butler became one of the 24 million Americans who help care for their aging and failing parents.”


Imagine a Medicare ‘Part Q’ for Quality at the End of Life is an article in the NY Times by Katie Butler that appeared by years after the publication of her book.  It begins:



"I spent the last Sunday of my father’s life sitting by his bed on the hospice unit in a small Connecticut hospital. He was dying of pneumonia, once called “the old man’s friend.” There was a nondenominational chapel down the hall, and a sheet cake in the kitchen. His hand was warm. Reassured by the quiet presence of the hospice nurses and feeling the mysterious quickening of life through his veins, I gave over to being his daughter and letting him be my father one last time."

Imagining Medicare Part Q

This is an extraordinary opinion piece:


By Katy Butler December 9, 2015 New York Times

(Katy Butler is the author of “Knocking on Heaven’s Door: The Path to a Better Way of Death” and the administrator of the Slow Medicine group on Facebook.)

The article is on the 2016 Class syllabus. 

Here are some references:

Katy Butler: Knocking on Heaven’s Door: The Path to a Better Way of Death. Scribner; Reprint edition (June 10, 2014) 
Notes on Knocking on Heaven's Door  .

Muriel Gillick (Interview): Caring for the frail, demented and dying. (Prolonging life at the expense of its quality can rob elderly people of peaceful, meaningful years.)  http://kohd-wc.blogspot.com/search/label/Gillick

Amy Berman.  The Niagara Falls Trajectory . https://nihrecord.nih.gov/newsletters/2012/09_14_2012/story3.htm

Veterans Association Home Based Primary Care Program.
http://www.va.gov/geriatrics/guide/longtermcare/home_based_primary_care.asp

Katy Butler’s Slow Medicine Public Face Book Group
https://www.facebook.com/groups/108731512508516/?fref=nf

An Interview with Marion Gillick

Caring for the frail, demented and dying.

Prolonging life at the expense of its quality can rob elderly people of peaceful, meaningful years, Muriel Gillick tells Les Olson.

Thursday, November 19, 2015

Toward Evidence-Based End-of-Life Care

The disquieting patterns of end-of-life care in the United States have been well documented. In the last month of life, one in two Medicare beneficiaries visits an emergency department, one in three is admitted to an intensive care unit, and one in five has inpatient surgery. But one of the most sobering facts is that no current policy or practice designed to improve care for millions of dying Americans is backed by a fraction of the evidence that the Food and Drug Administration would require to approve even a relatively innocuous drug.

See:
Toward Evidence-Based End-of-Life Care
Scott D. Halpern, M.D., Ph.D. N Engl J Med 2015; 373:2001-2003

Free Full Text Online.

Thursday, October 29, 2015

Deciding About Dying

This is a meaningful essay in the NY Times by Susan Gubar, a woman living with metastatic ovarian cancer.  She speaks from her heart, from "being there."

It begins with this memorable sentence: "We know little about death, after all: There are no survivors to tell the tale. But we do know something about dying."

Saturday, September 26, 2015

When it comes to end-of-life care, perhaps we do need a bigger hammer


 by Richard Sontheimer.

While sitting one evening with my terminally ill elderly mother, she again asked me to help her end her suffering.  This time it was, “Could you just go get the hammer and hit me in the head?” Her previous requests had included “Son, you are a doctor, can’t you do something to help me with this?”  And then, “They treat animals better than this.”

On previous occasions, I had to remind my mom that we lived in one of the 48 states in the USA that does not have a death-with-dignity euthanasia law.  Her response was, “Then can you move me to Oregon or Washington?”

Rick Sontheimer is an old friend of mine.  His article is well-written, deep and important.  You can access it at Kevinmd.com.

Sunday, July 26, 2015

Helping Patients and Doctors Talk About Death


"Medicare announced plans in July 2015 to reimburse doctors for talking with patients about what treatments they want — and don’t want — toward the end of life. This sensible, long-overdue proposal is likely to have a very wide impact. About 80 percent of people who die in the United States each year are covered by Medicare, and Medicare policies are often followed by private insurers, some of which already pay for these advance-planning conversations.



"Virtually all experts agree that medical professionals will need additional training. Many doctors are uncomfortable talking to patients about planning for death."



Sunday, July 5, 2015

How to Talk About Dying

by Ellen Goodman, NY Times, July 1, 2015


This is an extraordinary essay.  Well worth studying.  It’s common sense that we need to be reminded of.
Excerpts:
The difference between a good death and a hard death often seemed to hinge essentially on whether someone’s wishes were expressed and respected. Whether they’d had a conversation about how they wanted to live toward the end.

So, a small group of us — each with his or her own story — started the Conversation Project, a nonprofit, out of the belief that surely we could make this easier. (also see the Conversation "starter kit." Our partners at the Institute for Healthcare Improvement gathered experts frustrated at the pace of change who believed that the health care system wouldn’t change until the culture changed. So we are trying to change the culture.

There is now, finally, a real momentum for improving end-of-life care. The signs range from the Institute of Medicine’s report, “Dying in America,” to the success of Atul Gawande’s book “Being Mortal.”

There is also a growing public awareness of the need to break through the reluctance that has kept us tongue-tied for so long. A survey we did last year showed that 90 percent of Americans now think it’s important to have the conversation. But the same survey showed something else: Only 30 percent of us have actually had these conversations. So the gap remains huge.

From all the stories shared with us, we know that what people need most is help getting started. They need a travel guide to take the first steps down an unfamiliar and difficult road. So we created a ConversationStarter Kit.

Dying is not just a medical experience, it is also a deeply human experience.


Wednesday, February 25, 2015

The Conversation


A Revolutionary Plan for End-Of-Life Care

From Amazon:
There is an unspoken dark side of American medicine - keeping patients alive at any price. Two thirds of Americans die in healthcare institutions tethered to machines and tubes at bankrupting costs, even though research shows that most prefer to die at home in comfort, surrounded by loved ones.

Dr. Angelo E. Volandes believes that a life well lived deserves a good ending. Through the stories of seven patients and seven very different end-of-life experiences, he demonstrates that what people with a serious illness, who are approaching the end of their lives, need most is not new technologies but one simple thing: The Conversation. In this book, he argues for a radical re-envisioning of the patient-doctor relationship and offers ways for patients and their families to talk about this difficult issue to ensure that patients will be at the center and in charge of their medical care. 


This is a low book that the covers many aspects of end–of-life care. It will be useful to anyone who takes the time to read it. It compliments Gawande's Being Mortal. The Conversation is mostly directed to patients. Physicians may find it too simplistic, but it is still helpful in pointing out the discussions we should have with patients.


Volandes and his group have produced "The Conversation" videos which can be shown to patients to help with making end-of-life decisions. These videos are available at many institutions around the country. They would be helpful to have in an office setting, in addition. They can be shown on an iPad for convenience and portability. DJE
 

Sunday, February 8, 2015

When ‘Doing Everything’ Is Way Too Much


By Jessica Nutik Zitter   
New York Times, February 8, 2015

“In trying to honor Vincent’s autonomy, we abandoned him in hell.” This is a harrowing essay by an I.C.U. physician.  It covers many topics dealing with autonomy, advance directives and end-of-life care.  What Ivan Illich called “The Rule of Rescue” is highlighted.

Thursday, February 5, 2015

Death and Dignity — A Case of Individualized Decision Making


The following is a classic article about "assisted suicide" which appeared 24 years ago in the New England Journal of Medicine.  It is still a "keeper."

Death and Dignity — A Case of Individualized Decision Making
by Timothy E. Quill, M.D.
 N Engl J Med 1991; 324:691-694  Full Text PDF

"Diane was feeling tired and had a rash. A common scenario, though there was something subliminally worrisome that prompted me to check her blood count. Her hematocrit was 22, and the white-cell count was 4.3 with some metamyelocytes and unusual white cells. I wanted it to be viral, trying to deny what was staring me in the face. Perhaps in a repeated count it would disappear. I called Diane and told her it might be more serious than I had initially thought — that the test needed to be repeated and that if she felt worse, we might have to move quickly. When she pressed for the possibilities, I reluctantly opened the door to leukemia. Hearing the word seemed to make it exist. "Oh, shit!" she said. "Don't tell me that." Oh, shit! I thought, I wish I didn't have to."

See also:

By Lawrence K. Altman, Special to The New York Times
Published: March 7, 1991
Rochester, March 6— In a rare disclosure, a Rochester doctor has told how he prescribed the barbiturates that a 45-year-old female patient needed to kill herself after she refused treatment for a severe form of leukemia.




Monday, January 19, 2015

Marcia Angell's Review of Being Mortal


Karen Gunderscheimer, who is auditing our class, read a recent review of Gawande’s Being Mortal by Marcia Angell in the New York Review of Books.  Karen writes: “This [review] is well worth reading: lucid writing, beautifully developed, and also compelling. Angell is both author and physician.  She was the Executive Editor of the New England Journal of Medicine from 1988 – 2000.  Her very personal experiences with hospice are revelatory, her view on end of life issues is somewhat at odds with current thinking.

Her review: “A Better Way Out” is available free full text online.

Her husband’s Arnold “Bud” Relman’s essay entitled “On Breaking One’s Neck” is a companion piece. It also appeared in The New York Review of Books.

The Relman's were the ultimate "power couple" of American medicine.

The Relmans in Happier Days

Angel and Relman after Breaking His Neck
 

Saturday, January 17, 2015

Prescribing the End-of-Life Conversation


by Dr. Angelo Volandes (Boston Globe, January 11, 2015)

Image from The Globe article
"End-of-life care in America is broken at every level. A recent Institute of Medicine report paints a damning picture of end-of-life care in this country: It needs to be entirely overhauled. We live in a city with some of the best hospitals in the world, the “Wall Street” of American health care. I work in one of the best hospitals on earth, and I’ve watched patients die in ways that are protracted, dehumanizing, and far more painful than they needed to be."

"Sometimes, patients and families don’t want to face death. But more often, the problem lies with the medical profession. The principal reason we have gotten death so wrong is because doctors fail to have meaningful discussions with patients and their families about how to live life’s final chapter."

"Americans receive some of the best health care money can buy; they also experience some of the worst deaths in the developed world. By most accounts, the American transformation of death from a natural process occurring at home to a medicalized event taking place outside of the home has been disastrous. The health care system is teeming with brilliant scientists, but there is a dearth of effective communicators and advocates."

"What people need most on this journey is not the promise of the next new technology, but rather a guide to help them navigate this dark forest in which we all will undoubtedly find ourselves. People need doctors who are honest enough and capable of explaining new technologies with the accompanying risks and benefits, and discussing whether those technologies would truly benefit them."

The author has recently published a book on this topic, "The Conversation."

Thursday, September 25, 2014

Panel Urges Overhauling Health Care at End of Life


NY Times, September 7, 2014, by Pam Belluck
(The following are quotes from the Times article.)
 
Our health care system is poorly designed to meet the needs of patients near the end of life was the conclusion of a panel set up by the Institute of Medicine.  ““The current system is geared towards doing more, more, more, and that system by definition is not necessarily consistent with what patients want, and is also more costly.”

The panel called for “the elimination of “perverse financial incentives” that encourage expensive hospital procedures when growing numbers of very sick and very old patients want low-tech services like home health care and pain management.

The 507-page report, “Dying in America,” said its recommendations would improve the quality of care and better satisfy more patients and families. It also said the changes would produce significant savings that would help make health care more affordable.

“If you meet their needs, treat their pain, treat their depression, get them some help in the house, your costs plummet,” said Dr. Diane E. Meier, a committee member and the director of the Center to Advance Palliative Care. Fewer patients would end up in emergency rooms getting expensive care they do not want, she said, adding, “It’s a rare example in health policy of doing well by doing good.”

Perhaps, the committee’s most “radical conclusion” was that there should be a more pronounced shift away from fee-for-service medicine, which promotes an emphasis on medical interventions in part by reimbursing doctors based on procedures rather than for talking with patients.

In surveys of doctors about their own end-of-life preferences, “a vast majority want to be at home and as free of pain as possible, and yet that’s not what doctors practice.

“Patients don’t die in the manner they prefer,” Dr. Victor J. Dzau, the Institute of Medicine’s president, said at the briefing. “The time is now for our nation to develop a modernized end-of-life care system.”

Sunday, August 31, 2014

End of Life Discussions

from the NY Times, August 31, 2014:
Coverage for End-of-Life Talks Gaining Ground
It looks like Medicare will soon be covering end-of-life discussions between care-givers and patients.  This article is a great introduction to the topic and deserves a close reading.

Full article.